36 Gardiner's Bay Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Seasonal Rental

Active for Rent

4 Beds

3 Baths

Built In 1987

Listing ID	11654148



Property Type	House



County	Suffolk



Township	Shelter Island



Neighborhood	Hay Beach

School	SHELTER ISLAND UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT



Tax ID	0700-001.002-076-000.000



FEMA Flood Map	fema.gov/portal



Year Built	1987

Virtual Tour

GARDINER'S BAY WATERFRONT

RRN: 2025-L0086. This lovely contemporary just completed a down to the studs renovation. 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, dining room, living room with stone fireplace, finished lower level walkout, and multiple waterview terraces. High elevation with views of Gardiner's Bay, Gardiner's Island, and beyond. Your own private 107 feet of sugar sandy beach. One of the best beaches on Shelter Island and possibly the world! No, you're not in St. Bart's. It's Better!!! Available: MD-LD: $115K: July to LD: $95K, July: $45K, Aug 1 to Sept 7: $55K. All pricing plus utilities and services

MORE ▼

Property Details

4 Total Bedrooms
3 Full Baths
1.50 Acres
Built in 1987
Renovated 2025
3 Stories
Available 2/12/2026
Beach House Style
Full Basement
Lower Level: Finished, Walk Out
1 Lower Level Bedroom
1 Lower Level Bathroom

Rental Details

8 People Max
Internet
TV
Linens Included
Pets Allowed
Pet Notes: Some pets considered

Seasonal Rental

Period	Price	Dates	Status
July	$40,000	Jul 1st - Jul 31st 2026	Available
July/August-LD	$85,000	Jul 1st - Sep 7th 2026	Available
August-LD	$55,000	Aug 1st - Sep 7th 2026	Available
August	$45,000	Aug 1st - Aug 31st 2026	Available

Interior Features

Open Kitchen
Quartz Kitchen Counter
Oven/Range
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Microwave
Washer
Dryer
Appliance Hot Water Heater
Ceramic Tile Flooring
Hardwood Flooring
Furnished
Entry Foyer
Living Room
Dining Room
Den/Office
Walk-in Closet
Kitchen
Laundry
Private Guestroom
First Floor Bathroom
1 Fireplace
Forced Air
Heat Pump
3 Heat/AC Zones
Electric Fuel
Oil Fuel
Central A/C

Exterior Features

Frame Construction
Asphalt Shingles Roof
Private Well Water
Deck
Water View
Bay View
Bay Waterfront
Water Frontage: 110'

Community Details

Community: Hay Beach
Tennis Court
Golf
Clubhouse
Playground

Listed By

Mr. Angelo Piccozzi

DERING HARBOR REAL ESTATE LLC

Office: 631-456-0051

Mobile: 631-456-0051

Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.

Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent

Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:	I would like more information regarding the My State MLS Listing #11654148 at 36 Gardiner's Bay Drive, Shelter Island, NY.
Security:	What is 5 plus 5?