57 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,275,000 Sold Price

Sold on 9/05/2025

3 Beds

1.5 Baths

1790 SF

Built In 1900

Listing ID	11484608



Property Type	House



County	Suffolk



Township	Shelter Island

Tax ID	0700-014.000-0002-080.001



FEMA Flood Map	fema.gov/portal



Year Built	1900

Virtual Tour

Located in the Menantic area of Shelter Island on .57 acres and close to Heights shops, restaurants, beaches and ferry is this charming, updated Turn-Of-The Century Farmhouse. The house features a light-filled main floor living room, dining room, family-room, eat-in-kitchen with half bath and access to a sweet enclosed, screened porch that overlooks the landscaped back yard. The bright and sunny second floor has a spacious primary bedroom with adjoining office, full bath, and two additional bedrooms. There is a full, floored, storage attic and partial basement for laundry and utilities. The pool is fenced and landscaped with a convenient and newly roofed pool storage shed. A rocking chair, covered front porch and side patio add relaxing outdoor reading and dining areas to this lovely summer vacation or year round home.

MORE ▼

Property Details

3 Total Bedrooms
1 Full Bath
1 Half Bath
1790 SF (AG)
0.57 Acres
Built in 1900
2 Stories
Farmhouse Style
Partial Basement

Interior Features

Eat-In Kitchen
Oven/Range
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Washer
Dryer
Hardwood Flooring
Living Room
Dining Room
Family Room
Den/Office
Primary Bedroom
Kitchen
Baseboard
Oil Fuel

Exterior Features

Frame Construction
Cedar Clapboard Siding
Private Well Water
Private Septic
Pool: In Ground
Patio
Street View

Sale Information

Sold on 9/05/2025
Sold for $1,275,000

Previously Listed By

Gina Surerus

Corcoran Group (Shelter Island)

Office: 631-749-2521

Mobile: 631-276-3520

Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.

Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent

Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:	I would like more information regarding the My State MLS Listing #11484608 at 57 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY.
Security:	What is 8 plus 1?