44 St. Mary's Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

26 Photos
Active for Sale
3 Beds
4 Baths
4478 SF
Built In 1985
Listing ID 11096380
Property Type Residential
County Suffolk
Township Shelter Island
School Shelter Island
Tax ID 0700-015.000-0004-004.000
FEMA Flood Map fema.gov/portal
Year Built 1985
Virtual Tour
In real estate, opportunity is overarching. Here on Shelter Island, a significant canvas is presented for the next owner to "paint" their dream scenario on this horse farm with a setting in place for multiple equestrian enhancements. Across 8+ acres, there are currently three separate and distinct buildings providing ample room to use as-is or expand and significant space to build new, and more! One of the most unique offerings for this parcel, is the ability for the next to owner to subdivide. The next owner must do their own due diligence and go through the steps, but this property is prime for redevelopment. New Opportunities abound. Currently, the three (3) bedroom farm house is two stories with a finished basement, offering over 4,400 sq.ft. of total living space. The horse barn in the front of the property has multiple stalls including a tack room and loft space above. Additionally, there are two (2) large horse riding paddocks located in the front and rear of the property. The detached two car garage with separate hot water heater and generator has an apartment above and overlooks the in-ground 18' x 44' gunite pool. Commerce opportunity as well. For those interested, the current zoning of the parcel would allow the next owner to run a bed and breakfast on the property. Day visits to either Fork couldn't be easier, as the setting is ideally located just 5 minutes in either direction to the South or North Ferries. Dering Harbor is 4 minutes away.
Property Details
  • 3 Total Bedrooms
  • 4 Full Baths
  • 4478 SF
  • 8.45 Acres
  • Built in 1985
  • Colonial Style
  • Full Basement
  • Lower Level: Finished, Walk Out
Interior Features
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Furnished
  • Entry Foyer
  • Living Room
  • Dining Room
  • Family Room
  • Den/Office
  • Primary Bedroom
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Media Room
  • Bonus Room
  • Kitchen
  • 2 Fireplaces
  • Forced Air
  • Propane Fuel
Exterior Features
  • Detached Garage
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • Private Well Water
  • Private Septic
  • Pool: In Ground, Gunite, Heated
  • Deck
  • Patio
  • Barn
  • Guest House
  • Pool House
  • Riding Ring
  • Stable
  • Workshop
  • Outbuilding
  • Scenic View
Listed By
Request More Information
Request Showing
Your Preferred Date & Time
Showing Type:

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and PMI.

The amount you plan to offer for a home.
Cash you can pay when you close.
Varies depending on lender and credit score.
Affects interest rates. 30- or 15-year loans are standard.
Amortization Schedule

Advanced Options

Percentage of home's value. Varies by area.
Based on average insurance costs nationally.
Required if down payment is less than 20%. Rate depends on lender and credit score.
Fees paid in some shared complexes for maintenance.
Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Contact Us
Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent
Your Name:
Security: What is 7 plus 4?