5 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$4,950,000
Active for Sale
5 Beds
4.5 Baths
3206 SF
Built In 1860
 
Listing ID 11665202
Property Type Residential
County Suffolk
Township Shelter Island
Total Tax $26,438
Tax ID 0700-018.000-00-002.022
FEMA Flood Map fema.gov/portal
Year Built 1860
Virtual Tour

SHELTER ISLAND 1860 ITALIANATE WITH POOL AND DOCK

Set on 2.94 waterfront acres overlooking West Neck Creek, this 1860 Victorian stands with the quiet assurance of a home that has been well kept and thoughtfully expanded over time. From its slightly elevated position, lawns slope gently toward the water, framed by fruit trees and open sky. A long drive, marked by a traditional lantern, leads to the formal double-door entry. Inside, wide-plank pine floors speak to the home's early craftsmanship. The living room retains its original moldings, tall two-over-two windows, and a marble fireplace with summer cover. Beyond, the formal dining room mirrors these distinctive details and looks out toward the water. The kitchen is practical and well placed, with pantry storage and direct access to the outdoor entertaining areas. A first-floor parlor with full bathroom sits just off the foyer. Upstairs are four guest bedrooms, two of which have water views, a powder room, and a full hall bath. In the 1980's, a primary suite wing was seamlessly added, with careful attention to scale and proportion. Reached by a separate hallway with its own exterior entrance and independently heated, with access to lower level two car garage, the suite includes a sitting room with French doors to the grounds, a spacious bedroom, full bath, dressing area, walk-in closet, and office. Outdoors, a covered porch and deck with an electric awning overlook the 20 x 40 Gunite pool with bluestone surround/patio, positioned for captivating western sunsets, with outdoor shower close by. The 58 foot long, 4 foot wide fixed dock on protected West Neck Creek, with permits for two floating platforms, provides easy access to the harbor. A waterfront home of substance and history, shaped by time and oriented to the water.
Property Details
  • 5 Total Bedrooms
  • 4 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 3206 SF (AG)
  • 2.94 Acres
  • Built in 1860
  • Renovated 2010
  • 2 Stories
  • Available 2/28/2026
  • Traditional Style
  • Full Basement
  • Lower Level: Unfinished
  • Renovation: 1980's: Wing on north side w/living room, en-suite bedroom, office, oil heat,2c garage. 2010 dock/ramp/two floats; 2005: Gunite pool, stone patios, outdoor shower; 2003: 565-ft covered porch and deck. Whole house water filtration. 2 fireplaces are sealed.
Interior Features
  • Separate Kitchen
  • Laminate Kitchen Counter
  • Oven/Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Appliance Hot Water Heater
  • Ceramic Tile Flooring
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Entry Foyer
  • Living Room
  • Dining Room
  • Family Room
  • Formal Room
  • Den/Office
  • Study
  • Primary Bedroom
  • en Suite Bathroom
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Bonus Room
  • Great Room
  • Library
  • Kitchen
  • Private Guestroom
  • First Floor Primary Bedroom
  • First Floor Bathroom
  • 3 Fireplaces
  • Baseboard
  • Forced Air
  • 3 Heat/AC Zones
  • Oil Fuel
  • Propane Fuel
  • Central A/C
Exterior Features
  • Frame Construction
  • Wood Siding
  • Cedar Clapboard Siding
  • Cedar Shake Siding
  • Asphalt Shingles Roof
  • Built In (Basement) Garage
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • Private Well Water
  • Private Septic
  • Pool: In Ground, Gunite, Heated, Fencing
  • Pool Size: 20 x 40
  • Deck
  • Fence
  • Open Porch
  • Covered Porch
  • Outdoor Shower
  • Driveway
  • Trees
  • Subdivision: Menantic Colony
  • Water View
  • Creek View
  • Inlet View
  • Wooded View
  • Private View
  • Scenic View
  • Waterfront
  • Water Frontage: 257
Taxes and Fees
  • $26,438 Total Tax
Listed By
SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES
Office: 631-749-5801
Mobile: 917-208-5519
Request More Information
Request Showing
Role Agent Buyer
Your Preferred Date & Time
Showing Type:
Request Cobroke

If you're not a member, fill in the following form to request cobroke participation.

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and PMI.

The amount you plan to offer for a home.
Cash you can pay when you close.
Varies depending on lender and credit score.
Affects interest rates. 30- or 15-year loans are standard.
Amortization Schedule

Advanced Options

Percentage of home's value. Varies by area.
Based on average insurance costs nationally.
Required if down payment is less than 20%. Rate depends on lender and credit score.
Fees paid in some shared complexes for maintenance.
Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Contact Us
Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent
Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:
Security: What is 5 minus 3?